Plans for ‘marina village’ refused in closely tied vote

07:30 13 February 2013

People queued around the corner to get into the planning meeting at Bideford Town Hall this morning.

People queued around the corner to get into the planning meeting at Bideford Town Hall this morning.

Archant

It is not yet known if developers will appeal the decision by Torridge District Council.

CHEERS erupted from members of the public on Thursday morning as councillors voted to refuse an application for a 250-berth ‘marina village’ at Knapp House.

Five of the nine members of Torridge District Council’s planning committee voted to go with the recommendation made by planning officers to refuse the application.

The plans submitted by LTPH Properties included 295 new houses (38 of which would be affordable), 80 holiday homes and a 90-bed care home.

A site allocated for a primary school, retail units, a 40-bed hotel and a doctors’ surgery were also included in the plans.

Despite concerns raised about the site being in a coastal protection area, an increase in traffic, provision of low paid, seasonal jobs and the profitability of the marina, four councillors voted in favour of the application.

The main concern for most present at the meeting was that building houses next to Appledore shipyard, run by Babcock Marine, could create problems due to noise levels.

Town and district councillors speaking at the meeting were worried it could also stop any possible expansion of the shipyard in the future, which employs 350 people and 50 sub-contractors at present.

Lewis Andrews, planning executive for the council, said officers had balanced the issues surrounding the application but were ‘conclusive’ in recommending refusal.

Councillor Margaret Brown moved to refuse the application, and said: “I do think it detracts from the area, and there’s a threat to the shipyard and to future jobs.

“We need to protect our jobs; I believe any economic benefit that could be accrued from this development wouldn’t outweigh any adverse impacts on this sensitive area.”

But Councillor Kathy Murdoch said she thought if the marina worked, it could be ‘absolutely brilliant’ for the region and could bring in future investment.

Councillor Chris Leather, who also voted in favour of the marina plans, was booed by the crowd when he said the site was ‘of no major ecological value’ to him personally.

He said: “If we want the marina and feel it would be an asset, to make it viable we have got to put other things in there to pay for it.

“I’d like to see another hotel; we’re very short of hotels in the area and I think to make Knapp House into a 40-bed hotel is a brilliant scheme.”

Developer Paul Hevingham said the marina would provide hundreds of jobs and LTPH would work with the council to negotiate terms to protect the shipyard.

He said: “This development will create 305 new jobs in Torridge and 120 construction jobs over a period of at least six years; that’s one permanent job for every new house built.

“The noise generated by Babcock can be mitigated on this site and we will work together with them.”

But Councillor David Brenton, ward member for Bideford South, was sceptical of the developers’ promises.

“This deal has been sweetened so many times it’s the size of a gobstopper,” he said.

“That kind of environment; you can’t just recreate it.

“I’ll be in my wicker coffin and they’ll still be trying to build on it, but we have a duty for our children and grandchildren to protect what is over there.”

After hearing arguments on both sides Councillors Margaret Brown, Harold Martin, Howard Ratledge, David Lausen and Rosemary Lock voted in favour of refusing the development.

Councillors Peter Watson, Mervyn Langmead, Kathy Murdoch and Chris Leather voted against the refusal.

Speaking after the meeting, Northam town councillor Peter Hames who has campaigned against the development from the offset said it was a close call.

The developers were unavailable for comment and it is not yet known if they will be appealing the decision.

Related articles

0 comments

Other News Stories

Yesterday, 16:26
Withycombe primary school. Ref exe 16-16TI 9412. Picture: Terry Ife

A plan to build a four-classroom block at an Exmouth primary school has been backed by the town council.

Read more
Yesterday, 15:12
Adam Joy and Maggie Frith and (inset) John Challis, Coolio and Chesney Hawkes on the video.

Actor from Barnstaple spent seven months enlisting the help of various celebrities to help with proposal.

Read more
Yesterday, 15:00
Some of the Seaton Jubilee Aristst Group's  works that are going on show at Pecorama

An exhibition of works by members of the Seaton Jubilee Artists’ Group will open at Beer tomorrow (Thursday, September 1).

Read more
Yesterday, 13:54

Revised plans to build eight new homes in Exmouth have been approved by East Devon District Council.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:30
Pictured here; the most topical – and controversial – is a play on the infamous wall that presidential candidate Donald Trump said he would build to keep Mexicans out of the United States.

Controversial and topical toys are coming to Exmouth’s Rolle Centre as part of an exhibition to highlight serious subjects.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:27
Pilton Park in Barnstaple was under water this morning (Friday). Pic by Brian Saunders

North Devon Council’s executive committee will discuss the flood defence plan on Monday.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:30
The derelict Brunswick Wharf site in Bideford. Picture: Sarah Howells

The prime waterside development site in Bideford is set to go back up for tender as council confirms it has terminated contract with developer.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:26
Shot from Dave Robson's BASE jumping film 'The Exit Point'

A former Exmouth Community College student, inspired by a popular television programme, has created his own BASE jumping film.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:00
Jane Hawking pictured at her Cambridge home [Picture: Masons Agency]

What was it like being married to Britain’s best-known genius, Stephen Hawking, for nearly 30 years and cope with his equally famous, progressive neurodegenerative Lou Gehrig’s Disease?

Read more
Yesterday, 11:00
David,Henry,Edmee and John Greenshields at the Honiton Hill Rally. Ref mhh 35-16TI 6814. Picture: Terry Ife

This year’s Honiton Hill Rally was hit with unpredictable weather - enjoying sunny skies and rain showers all within 48 hours.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 17°C

min temp: 11°C

Most Read News

Place a family notice

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

Find a job in Devon



Local business directory

Devon's trusted business finder

FFind planning applications