Council criticised over site visit ‘shambles’

13:25 21 November 2012

Torridge District Council has been criticised for not turning up to wind turbine appeals.

Torridge District Council has been criticised for not turning up to wind turbine appeals.

Archant

An inspector calls – but Torridge planning officers turn up 40 minutes late to one wind turbine appeal and miss the other completely.

TORRIDGE District Council has come under fire for failing to defend its own decisions on wind turbine developments.

Officers from the council twice failed to turn up to site visits with Government planning inspectors in the space of three weeks.

The applications – one for a 46-metre-high turbine at Huxhill Farm and another for a 25-metre turbine at Higher Huxhill Farm, both near Gammaton Cross on the outskirts of Bideford – were refused planning permission by the council in the summer.

The decisions have since been appealed by both applicants and site visits arranged to allow inspectors from Bristol to see the locations before deciding whether to uphold the appeals.

On October 9, a site visit at Huxhill Farm went ahead 40 minutes late after a member of the public walked up a hill to phone the council’s planning office and inform them of the visit.

The council said it ‘knew nothing’ about the visit but eventually sent an officer to join the planning inspector, as well as the appellant, agent and around six objectors, who are now anxiously awaiting a decision by the inspector.

Then on October 31, a similar inspection at Higher Huxhill Farm was abandoned by an inspector after an officer from the council failed to turn up at all.

This time the inspector tried to raise the council herself but nobody answered the phone so she abandoned the meeting. A visit has since been re-scheduled for November 30.

“We thought they’d learned their lesson after the first visit but then the same thing happened three weeks later,” said objector Patrick Smith, who lives around 600 metres from both sites.

“I felt highly embarrassed for the inspector, who came a long way to take the site visit.

“We have done everything we can under difficult circumstances to oppose this application; we have to be realistic, and are not hopeful, but all we wanted was an orderly site visit to take place.

“It is an appalling indictment of Torridge District Council planning who are supposed to be defending the plans committee’s refusal of this application.”

In an email to Mr Smith, Kate Little, the council’s head of planning, blamed the non-attendance on an ‘administrative error’.

She said: “This is a matter of human error and not a systems failure. The council would never deliberately miss a site visit or seek to delay it and we will be apologising to the appellant and the inspector who do have the right to expect us to turn up.”

Council leader Councillor Barry Parsons said: “It’s disappointing there has been an oversight but we will aim to make sure nothing like this happens again.”

It is not the first time that the Huxhill Farm application has caused controversy. In July, the district council was criticised for its ‘heavy handed’ approach after fielding police and security guards to manage crowds at a planning meeting at Riverbank House.

Mr Smith said he had made a formal complaint to the district council about the planning department and was considering making a complaint to the Local Government Ombudsman.

He said: “It all comes down to their poor communication system. Letters are not acknowledged and phone calls are not answered.”

“The council is failing to mount a ‘robust’ defence of its own decisions; if these turbines get built you won’t see trees in Torridge for turbines,” he added.

“We’re going to be stuck with these things for the next 25-30 years – I think they are targeting Torridge because it’s a soft touch.”

Cllr Barry Parsons said: “The plans committee at Torridge always determines applications on their own merit and although wind turbine applications can be controversial each brings its own individual elements to be considered.

“Decisions made are based on planning considerations and are often a balancing act with the sustainable energy benefits being weighed up against environmental impact.

“Plans committee members often have a difficult job but are trained to understand the implications and approve or refuse applications based on the information presented to them.”

0 comments

Other News Stories

Yesterday, 19:59
Diesel's family and friends with their tribute to him at Ilfracombe Carnival 2016. Picture: Tony Gussin

Costumed mayhem as Ilfracombe celebrates carnival night

Read more
Yesterday, 17:30
Various fruits and vegetables on counter

Blustery weather and rain failed to dampen spirits at the 54th Upottery Flower and Vegetable Show.

Read more
Yesterday, 16:58
Greater horseshoe bats

Appeal reached 80 per cent of £26,000 target in just one month - but more support needed

Read more
Yesterday, 15:00
Carol Gilson.

A Honiton mobility scheme has enhanced the life of two people.

Read more
Yesterday, 12:30
The Morris Minor owners club car show took place at the weekend. John, Susannah, Julie, Samuel and Margaret Dawkins with the family 1968 Morris Minor convertible. Ref exe 34-16AW 4357. Picture: Alex Walton.

A classic car show hit top gear in Exmouth as it raised money for Devon Air Ambulance.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:40
Macmillan volunteers at a street collection in Sidmouth on Saturday.

Fundraisers who have netted £175,000 for a charity in 15 years are ‘desperately’ appealing for volunteers to keep campaigning.

Read more
Yesterday, 11:00
Partnership manager Richard Burningham (leftt) with Richard Kempton of South West Trains holding copies of the new “Devon – Great Scenic Railways” booklet.

East Devon and the Axminster to Exeter railway line is to be more widely promoted across the region, thanks to a new initiative.

Read more
Yesterday, 09:03
Red Arrows at Sidmouth 2016. Ref shs 34-16TI 6349. Picture: Terry Ife

The Red Arrows put on a fantastic display at Sidmouth to a bumper crowd on Friday evening, the weather was just perfect for such an event.

Read more
Yesterday, 07:00
The cycling team who are all hoping to raise £1,000 for a good cause.

A trio of cyclists embarked on a charity challenge and climbed more than 24,000 feet in 24 hours over the weekend.

Read more
Yesterday, 06:35
The Sidmouth whicker donkey

A mystery over Sidmouth Bowling Club’s missing ‘lucky’ wicker donkey has been solved - after it was revealed the mascot has taken a holiday.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 21°C

min temp: 12°C

Most Read News

Place a family notice

Family Notices 24

Newsletter Sign Up

Find a job in Devon



Local business directory

Devon's trusted business finder

FFind planning applications